Benchmarking  
  Audit  
  Energy Rating  
  Promotion  
  ESCO Support  
  Demonstration
Projects
 
  Local Equipment Manufacturers  
  EE Financing  
 
   

 

 

Motor Guideline

Energy Savings by retrofitting VSD on PRIMARY CHILLED WATER PUMPs for a semiconductor factory

Title Energy Savings by retrofitting of Variable Speed Drive (VSD) to bring back to original design flow for Primary Chilled Water PUMPs in a semiconductor factory
Purpose
To carry out retrofitting of 3 x 55kW VSD for a Primary Chilled Water PUMPs. The existing Primary Chilled Water PUMPs operate for 24 hours and the balancing valve is partially closed to maintain the design flow condition.
Control
logi
c
Before retrofit
After retrofit
 
case12_graph1

A Primary Chilled Water Pump in Primary/Secondary pumping HVAC system application is designed to maintain a constant flow through cooler of the chiller. The Primary/Secondary pumping technique decouples the “primary” production loop from the “secondary” distribution loop. This allows chillers to obtain constant design flow and operate properly while allowing the rest of the system (Secondary Pumping) to vary in flow.

In Primary Chilled water system, the pumps is sized to handle the chiller cooler design flow rate at a discharge pressure just high enough to circulate the water through the cooler of the chiller and the rest of the primary piping loop.

The primary pump flow is traditionally controlled by throttling valves or balancing valve on the discharge side of the pump. The pumps are often oversized due to safety margin in the designs. By adding losses to the pumping circuit with the throttling valve, the proper design flow rate can be established.

The primary pump before retrofitting is controlled by throttling valve which is partially closed.

graph2
 
figure3

VSD were added to the primary pumping to replace the throttling valves. The throttling valve will be FULLY OPENED; VSD will act as “electronic valve” to bring the flow back to design condition. There are two possible control methods:

1) Using the flowmeter. Because the desire design flow rate is known and is constant, a flow meter can be installed at the discharge of each chiller and the analogue output from the flowmeter controlled the pump directly.

2)Using local speed determination. The speed was manually decreased until design flow rate is achieved. Differential pressure sensors can be used by locating across each chiller. Differential pressure across a non modulating load also measure flow.

In this application, differential pressure sensors were being used.

Retrofitting

1. Retrofitting of 3 x 55kW VSD for existing Primary Chilled Water Pumps

2. Installation of differential pressure sensor for the Primary Chilled Water pumps control
3. Modification of auto-trans control panel
Result in savings FIELD SURVEY OF EXISTING CONDITIONS (in Year 1999)

1.0 CHILLER DESIGN DATA and OPERATING DATA

1.1 Existing Equipment for Chilled Water System

The Central Chilled Water System comprises of:
• 5 units 750 Tons Centrifugal Chillier.
• 5 units 55KW Chilled Water (CHW) pumps.
• 4 units 45KW Condenser water (CW) pumps and 1 unit 55KW Condenser water (CW) pump.

Chilled Water Plant Operation:
During the time of survey, there are 3 chillers, 3 CHW pumps and 3 CW pumps in 24 hours operation. All the data listed below were collected from Chiller # 2 & CHWP # 2 .


1.2 Design Data:

Chiller Design Data Design Flow Design Pressure Drop
Evaporator 1,500 USGPM (95 L/s) 30.0 ft WG (12.9 psi)
Condenser 2,250 USGPM (142 L/s) 12.3 ft WG (5.3 psi)


1.3 Actual Operating Data:

Chiller Operating Data Operating Pressure Drop
Evaporator 26.0 psi
Condenser 5.0 psi


2.0 PRIMARY CHILLED WATER PUMPS

2.1 Design Data

Pumps Design head Design flow Powe/Fla
CHWP 2 124 ft WG 95 L/s (1500 USGPM 55KW / 99A

2.2 Actual operating conditions :

i) Valve Balanced (partially throttled)

Pumps Actual head Actual flow VAC / FLA / Consumed Power
CHWP 2 124 ft WG 95 L/s (1500 USGPM) 441VAC / 74.9A / 49.8KW

An Energy Saving Software (HVAC Tool Box II) was used to calculate the energy consumption.

table1

table2



table3_case11

ii) Valve Fully Open

Pumps Actual head Actual flow VAC / FLA / Consumed Power
CHWP 2 112 ft WG 119 L/s (1880 USGPM) 119 L/s (1880 USGPM)


table4_case11

table5_case11

Analysis and re commendations:

Based on the above collected data, the actual flow of chilled water circuit appears to be higher than the design flow (approximately 25% over the design flow). In order to avoid wasting the energy by pumping extra water in the chilled water circuit, variable speed drive (VSD) was recommended to be fixed to the chilled water pumps to bring the actual flow of chilled water circuit back to the design.

This will help to reduce the energy consumption of the pump and improve the
efficiency of the chiller due to the improved performance of heat exchanger.

3.0 Energy Consumption for Chilled Water Pump:
Annual power consumption of each CHWP = 430,118 KWH /year

Annual power consumption of each CHWP
installed with VSD = 298,829 KWH /year

Total KWH saving for each CHWP = 131,289 KWH/year
Total KWH saving for 3 units CHWP = 3 x 131,289 KWH/year
= 393,867 KWH/year

Amortisation Analysis:
Electricity cost (Tariff C2): RM 0.128 / KWHr (Off-peak Period)
RM 0.208 / KWHr (Peak Period)
RM 25.70 / KWHr (Maximum Demand)

Annual cost saving =
(393,867 x 0.128 x 14 / 24) + (393,867 x 0.208 x 10 / 24) + (393,867/ 8760 x 25.70 x 12)
= RM 29,408.74 + RM 34,135.14 + RM 13,866.27 = RM 77,410.15

Total installation cost (VSD + panel modification + sensors + system balancing ) = RM140,000

Therefore, Return of Investment (ROI) = Savings/Investment = <1.9 year

 

Source: Danfoss Industries Sdn Bhd